Fizik Antares Saddle
Bikes | 1986 Nishiki Intl | 1999 Fuji Team | 1994 Steelman | 1998 Turner | 1990 Steelman | 2000 Hunter Cross | Teschner | Scott Plasma | Cervelo R3 | SRAM Red | Fizik Antares | | eebrake | Home
I decided to compare the Antares not only to it's brethren but also to the Selle Italia SLR. Here's how they measured up:
Comparing the saddles
I purchased the Aliante about 9 months ago -- and found it to be the absolutely most comfortable saddle I've ever tried. I believe the secret to the Aliante's comfort is its suspension; the seat is suspended like a hammock. Notice the gold mesh in the picture above; it's essentially a fabric weave that allows floatation. The Airone and Antares have more traditional carbon shells (as does the SLR). The Aliante is supremely comfortable whether pushed back against the upraised back or pushed forward on the padded nose. With the Aliante, it feels like you sit "in" the saddle versus being perched "on" it. I can't say enough great things about the Aliante.
So how would the Antares fair? Oddly, the Antares is the widest of the bunch and slightly longer than the Aliante. It has a much slimmer profile and weighs a very respectable 177 grams (there is a carbon railed version with a claimed weight of 145 grams that costs $30 more). At first look, I thought it would mimic the feel of the Selle Italia SLR: ridable but not exactly comfortable. Amazingly, the Antares was fantastic. Despite it's slim profile, the padding is dense yet comfortable and it's width fully supports your sit bones. As with the Aliante, it was comfortable sitting toward the rear yet still offered enough padding in the nose for spinning up hills. The saddle was very comfortable over a 40+ mile ride, something I could never say about the Selle Italia SLR. I'm looking forward to trying this on my tri bike--as I the nose has more extension than the Aliante while also offering enough cushion for forward position aero-bar riding.
Overall, I still think the Aliante is the most comfortable road bike saddle--ever. The Antares is my second favorite saddle -- a lightweight alternative for the weight weenie crowd that might even prove to be a good solution for triathlons and time trials. I'll update this review when I've spent some time on the tri bike with it.
Value: 4 stars (50$ less than the Aliante)